OP
OP
-
This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
Woman in India Marries Dog to Ward Off Evil
- Thread starter prasad1
- Start date
- Status
Then why on earth did Adi Shankara put an end to the human sacrifice of the Bhairava cult?
So Adi S did not appreciate local culture I guess.
Lord Rama need not have gone after Ravan for kidnapping Seeta..He should have respected Ravan's appetite for females.
So you see we HAVE to respect Local Culture!
Sit back and enjoy!
Why complain that Culture is on the decline..we have to respect the new invading western culture!
Dont complain about intercaste marriage..if people can marry dogs at least be happy our children married a human!....respect the new culture!LOL
Now what about Gotra change in a non human and human marriage?
I really wonder??LOL
So Adi S did not appreciate local culture I guess.
Lord Rama need not have gone after Ravan for kidnapping Seeta..He should have respected Ravan's appetite for females.
So you see we HAVE to respect Local Culture!
Sit back and enjoy!
Why complain that Culture is on the decline..we have to respect the new invading western culture!
Dont complain about intercaste marriage..if people can marry dogs at least be happy our children married a human!....respect the new culture!LOL
Now what about Gotra change in a non human and human marriage?
I really wonder??LOL
Last edited:
dear RR ji,
So you feel that its a stupid marriage!LOL
Well ..I felt the marriage was an act of being misinformed!
Its not my imagination running wild but gotra of a female is supposed to change during the act of marriage and not after giving birth to an offspring..so here 1st she has Canine Gotra..then it has to be changed to a human gotra after she marries a human male...I guess someone will then ask her to do some pariharams for that.
BTW if the dog dies..does she become a widow?
You see RR ji..all these are important becos its a marriage..we have to respect Local Culture..We cant say its stupid!LOL
Last edited:
Raji Ram
Active member
Dear Renu,
1. I never said it was a good marriage. In fact I did not use the word wedding because of the reason I had already written
in our forum. Hope you remember that!
2. Nothing misinformed. It is a belief of some uncivilized people!
3. Gotra is only for a few castes, I guess! Does that female have a gotra for herself? :noidea:
OK! Even if she becomes 'canine gotra', she will automatically take her human husband's gotra later on!
I remember someone was trying to change the gotra of a widowed lady he married and it was told by members that she will
take the new husband's gotra automatically, after the wedding!
4. I think so! But widow remarriages DO happen!
5. Unless some Guru (from our forum?!!) is respected (!!) by those set of people who got the girl married to a dog, it is not
possible to change their custom and tradition! So better :tape:
dear RRji,
My answers in black.
My answers in black.
Dear Renu,
1. I never said it was a good marriage. In fact I did not use the word wedding because of the reason I had already written
in our forum. Hope you remember that!
2. Nothing misinformed. It is a belief of some uncivilized people!
Dear RR ji..why so harsh? Uncivilized is too harsh..misinformed is a better word.
3. Gotra is only for a few castes, I guess! Does that female have a gotra for herself? :noidea:
Well do any females of any caste have Gotras to start with?
After all the Gotra is Y chromosome linked..females dont have Gotras I guess of which ever Varna they are from..hence thats why change is allowed.
OK! Even if she becomes 'canine gotra', she will automatically take her human husband's gotra later on!
yes yes...someone might actually start a thread here asking about it in the future!LOL
4. I think so! But widow remarriages DO happen!
BTW how did the dog go around the fire or did the dog tie the mangalsutra(if this community had the mangalsutra)
5. Unless some Guru (from our forum?!!) is respected (!!) by those set of people who got the girl married to a dog, it is not
possible to change their custom and tradition! So better :tape:
The priest of the ares should educate the community.
Let me email Hindu Jagruti Samaj on this and tell them to look into the matter..they always want to jump into action..so let them jump into this.
Will email them now
Brahmanyan
Active member
"பாரத ஜனங்களின் தற்கால நிலைமை"
என்ற தலைப்பில் அன்றைய பாரதவாசிகளின் நிலைமையை கண்டு மனம் வெதும்பி மகாகவி பாரதியார் நெஞ்சு பொறுக்காமல் கவிதைவடிவில் தனது இதயத்தை திறந்து கூவினார்.
"நெஞ்சு பொறுக்கு திலையே! – இந்த
நிலைகெட்ட மனிதரை நினைந்துவிட்டால்,
அஞ்சி யஞ்சிச் சாவார் – இவர்
அஞ்சாத பொருளில்லை அவனியிலே
வஞ்சனைப் பேய்கள் என்பார் – இந்த
மரத்தில் என்பார்; அந்தக் குளத்தில் என்பார்
துஞ்சுது முகட்டில் என்பார் – மிகத்
துயர்ப்படுவார் எண்ணிப் பயப்படுவார். (நெஞ்சு)
மந்திர வாதி என்பார் – சொன்ன
மாத்திரத்தி லேமனக் கிலிபிடிப்பார்,
யந்திர சூனி யங்கள் – இன்னும்
எத்தனை ஆயிரம் இவர் துயர்கள்!
தந்த பொருளைக் கொண்டே – ஜனம்
தாங்குவர் உலகத்தில் அரசரெல்லாம
அந்த அரசியலை – இவர்
அஞ்சுதரு பேயென்றெண்ணி நெஞ்சம் அயர்வார். (நெஞ்சு)"
மேலும்,
"நெஞ்சு பொறுக்கு திலையே இந்த நிலைகெட்ட மனிதரை நினைந்துவிட்டால்... எண்ணிலா நோயுடையார்... கண் இல்லா குழந்தைகள் போல் பிறர் காட்டிய வழியில் சென்று மாட்டிக்கொள்வார்
நண்ணிய பெருங்கலைகள் பத்து நாலாயிரம் கோடி நயந்து நின்ற புண்ணிய நாட்டினிலே இவர் பொறியற்ற விலங்குகள் போல வாழ்வார்." என்று முடிக்கின்றார் பாரதியார்.
ஆனால் இன்று மகா கவி பாரதியார் இருந்து மக்களின் மூட செயல்களைக் கண்டால் காலம் இன்னமும் மாறவில்லையே மனம் குமுறி இருப்பார் !
அன்பன்,
ப்ரஹ்மண்யன்,
பெங்களூரு.
என்ற தலைப்பில் அன்றைய பாரதவாசிகளின் நிலைமையை கண்டு மனம் வெதும்பி மகாகவி பாரதியார் நெஞ்சு பொறுக்காமல் கவிதைவடிவில் தனது இதயத்தை திறந்து கூவினார்.
"நெஞ்சு பொறுக்கு திலையே! – இந்த
நிலைகெட்ட மனிதரை நினைந்துவிட்டால்,
அஞ்சி யஞ்சிச் சாவார் – இவர்
அஞ்சாத பொருளில்லை அவனியிலே
வஞ்சனைப் பேய்கள் என்பார் – இந்த
மரத்தில் என்பார்; அந்தக் குளத்தில் என்பார்
துஞ்சுது முகட்டில் என்பார் – மிகத்
துயர்ப்படுவார் எண்ணிப் பயப்படுவார். (நெஞ்சு)
மந்திர வாதி என்பார் – சொன்ன
மாத்திரத்தி லேமனக் கிலிபிடிப்பார்,
யந்திர சூனி யங்கள் – இன்னும்
எத்தனை ஆயிரம் இவர் துயர்கள்!
தந்த பொருளைக் கொண்டே – ஜனம்
தாங்குவர் உலகத்தில் அரசரெல்லாம
அந்த அரசியலை – இவர்
அஞ்சுதரு பேயென்றெண்ணி நெஞ்சம் அயர்வார். (நெஞ்சு)"
மேலும்,
"நெஞ்சு பொறுக்கு திலையே இந்த நிலைகெட்ட மனிதரை நினைந்துவிட்டால்... எண்ணிலா நோயுடையார்... கண் இல்லா குழந்தைகள் போல் பிறர் காட்டிய வழியில் சென்று மாட்டிக்கொள்வார்
நண்ணிய பெருங்கலைகள் பத்து நாலாயிரம் கோடி நயந்து நின்ற புண்ணிய நாட்டினிலே இவர் பொறியற்ற விலங்குகள் போல வாழ்வார்." என்று முடிக்கின்றார் பாரதியார்.
ஆனால் இன்று மகா கவி பாரதியார் இருந்து மக்களின் மூட செயல்களைக் கண்டால் காலம் இன்னமும் மாறவில்லையே மனம் குமுறி இருப்பார் !
அன்பன்,
ப்ரஹ்மண்யன்,
பெங்களூரு.
பிரஹ்மன்யன் சார்
நீங்கள் மேற்கோள் காட்டிய பாரதியாரின் கவிதை இந்த வேளையில் மிகவும் சாலச் சிறந்தது.
ஆனால் நாட்டினிலே நாம் மதம் என்கிற பேரினாலும், பாரம்பரியம் என்கிற பேரினாலும், கலாச்சாரம் என்கிற பேரினாலும் செய்யும் அனைத்திற்குமே, காரண, காரியம் கண்டுபிடிப்பதில் சிக்கல் உள்ளது.
இதனால் யாருக்காவது உடல், மன ரீதியில் தொல்லை வருமேயானால் அவற்றை விட்டொழிப்பதில் தவறு இல்லை.
ஆனால் எல்லாவற்றையும் ஒதுக்குவது என்பது சரி என தோன்றவில்லை
Last edited:
Raji Ram
Active member
Dear Renu,
My comments in blue!
1.Dear RR ji..why so harsh? Uncivilized is too harsh..misinformed is a better word.
Oh! You want to be polite to such people? :lol:
2. Well do any females of any caste have Gotras to start with?
After all the Gotra is Y chromosome linked..females dont have Gotras I guess of which ever Varna they are from..
hence thats why change is allowed.
A female has a Gotra, Renu! Till her wedding her father's and after the wedding her husband's! So...She HAS!!
3. yes...someone might actually start a thread here asking about it in the future!LOL
You have already asked in this thread itself!
4. BTW how did the dog go around the fire or did the dog tie the mangalsutra(if this community had the mangalsutra)
We don't have any idea of the rituals during such a wedding. We actually need one upload of this event on youtube! :ranger:
5. The priest of the area should educate the community.
May be, the priest of that area told this parihAram! :dizzy:
6. Let me email Hindu Jagruti Samaj on this and tell them to look into the matter..they always want to jump into action..
so let them jump into this.
Will email them now.
Good move, Renu! :thumb:
My comments in blue!
1.Dear RR ji..why so harsh? Uncivilized is too harsh..misinformed is a better word.
Oh! You want to be polite to such people? :lol:
2. Well do any females of any caste have Gotras to start with?
After all the Gotra is Y chromosome linked..females dont have Gotras I guess of which ever Varna they are from..
hence thats why change is allowed.
A female has a Gotra, Renu! Till her wedding her father's and after the wedding her husband's! So...She HAS!!
3. yes...someone might actually start a thread here asking about it in the future!LOL
You have already asked in this thread itself!
4. BTW how did the dog go around the fire or did the dog tie the mangalsutra(if this community had the mangalsutra)
We don't have any idea of the rituals during such a wedding. We actually need one upload of this event on youtube! :ranger:
5. The priest of the area should educate the community.
May be, the priest of that area told this parihAram! :dizzy:
6. Let me email Hindu Jagruti Samaj on this and tell them to look into the matter..they always want to jump into action..
so let them jump into this.
Will email them now.
Good move, Renu! :thumb:
Dear RR ji,
Black are my answers.
Black are my answers.
Oh! You want to be polite to such people? :lol:
Why use the term such people? They are also Hindus and humans.We dont lose anything being polite..if it works! If we want to help someone we first need to be polite to them.If we are hostile they too will be hostile.
BTW by calling them "such people" that shows that one feels they are lesser than others..this could explain the apathy as 'we bother'
Ever spoken to a Christian Preacher..they maintain politeness till the end even though they have an ulterior motive.
A female has a Gotra, Renu! Till her wedding her father's and after the wedding her husband's! So...She HAS!!
If something that is subject to change does not pass the test of time..that shows it was false to start with..false is the same as absent.
May be, the priest of that area told this parihAram! :dizzy:
Then the priest too needs to be educated!LOL
Raji Ram
Active member
Dear Renu,
I have tried a few times to be polite to such people right from my childhood.
And........ never did they respond in a polite manner. It is my experience.
I think I wrote earlier in forum but worth repeating for the sake of new members.
I was coming home for a holiday travelling by bus when I was a teenager. I sat near some sc / st female who might not have
had a bath for weeks. Since my parents had taught about toleration, I did so. Then one old lady, equally stinking, boarded the
bus and then I politely offered my seat to her. She almost pounced at me saying, 'nee pAppAththip puLLa. kaNdava kitteyum
ukkaruva. nAn appadi illa!' She could find the caste of the female just by a glance! How is that?
This is just a sample.
P.S: In most of the cases, 'kulaththaLavE Agum guNam' (Quote from avvaiyAr's 'moodhurai') is very true! :nod:
I have tried a few times to be polite to such people right from my childhood.
And........ never did they respond in a polite manner. It is my experience.
I think I wrote earlier in forum but worth repeating for the sake of new members.
I was coming home for a holiday travelling by bus when I was a teenager. I sat near some sc / st female who might not have
had a bath for weeks. Since my parents had taught about toleration, I did so. Then one old lady, equally stinking, boarded the
bus and then I politely offered my seat to her. She almost pounced at me saying, 'nee pAppAththip puLLa. kaNdava kitteyum
ukkaruva. nAn appadi illa!' She could find the caste of the female just by a glance! How is that?
This is just a sample.
P.S: In most of the cases, 'kulaththaLavE Agum guNam' (Quote from avvaiyAr's 'moodhurai') is very true! :nod:
Raji Ram
Active member
Dear Renu,
My wits should be at least equal to that old female, right? :boink:
But, I can't say equal because she could identify the subsect in that ST/SC and knew that
she was in a higher level whereas, I could not find it out!
Last edited:
Raji Ram
Active member
Dear Renu,
Sometimes I get whatever I wish, very soon!
This evening a TV channel telecast the dog-girl wedding.
1. Many men were dancing with swords and drums.
2. The smiling bride came out well dressed and sat on the place of marriage!
3. The decorated dog groom was brought in a car and made to sit near the bride.
4. A priest was doing the rituals with concentration.
5. The thirumAngalyam was kept on the forelegs of the groom and tied around the bride's neck, by a female!
6. The groom, not aware of the happenings, fell asleep!
Watch the video here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ZWzsIc2Rn0
P.S: The girl says that she is not happy by this marriage but believes that the evil spell on her will be transferred to the dog!
Poor creature!! :tsk:
Sometimes I get whatever I wish, very soon!
This evening a TV channel telecast the dog-girl wedding.
1. Many men were dancing with swords and drums.
2. The smiling bride came out well dressed and sat on the place of marriage!
3. The decorated dog groom was brought in a car and made to sit near the bride.
4. A priest was doing the rituals with concentration.
5. The thirumAngalyam was kept on the forelegs of the groom and tied around the bride's neck, by a female!
6. The groom, not aware of the happenings, fell asleep!
Watch the video here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ZWzsIc2Rn0
P.S: The girl says that she is not happy by this marriage but believes that the evil spell on her will be transferred to the dog!
Poor creature!! :tsk:
tks
0
Dear Renu,
Sometimes I get whatever I wish, very soon!
This evening a TV channel telecast the dog-girl wedding.
1. Many men were dancing with swords and drums.
2. The smiling bride came out well dressed and sat on the place of marriage!
3. The decorated dog groom was brought in a car and made to sit near the bride.
4. A priest was doing the rituals with concentration.
5. The thirumAngalyam was kept on the forelegs of the groom and tied around the bride's neck, by a female!
6. The groom, not aware of the happenings, fell asleep!
Watch the video here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ZWzsIc2Rn0
P.S: The girl says that she is not happy by this marriage but believes that the evil spell on her will be transferred to the dog!
Poor creature!! :tsk:
Poor creature is actually very cute ! I dont think anyone seem to mistreat him
Video shows everyone having a fun time and the cute dog taking a nice nap ..
I hope the teen girl ends up getting happily married (I mean to a man of her dreams)- let us offer our mental blessings to the teen girl who had to undergo this ritual.
Utter stupidity!
There is another twist to this. The video may be fake or stage managed because - the girl is fair and is quite unlike her parents; her language and diction is more gentile and appears rehearsed; people around her are dressed differently and behave differently; hosted by barcraft-tv which specializes in sensational video.
Will not be surprised if a hindu loather financed the whole deal for own promotion and eventual recognition from channels like ndtv and timesnow.
Will not be surprised if a hindu loather financed the whole deal for own promotion and eventual recognition from channels like ndtv and timesnow.
tks
0
Interesting observation. The video is well edited from segments each of which are well taken.
It is more likely than not that it is staged. There is a dog fight to come up with sensational stories.
Regardless, I do not understand some of the intolerant comments. In India we have temple for live rats. We have swamis who create things out of thin air . There will always be a good number of followers for any idea for any ritual or for any swamis in India.
The swamis are more dangerous in my view because they can get away with anything. One well known swami is known to indulge in his gay activities with young boys taking advantage of them using his god status in their minds much like some of the priests of Catholics faith that the new Pope has strongly come out against.
Most people tend to respect and even accept other traditions if they are based on harmless beliefs even if they are outlandish.
The most harmful aspect of this story is the notion that a young girl is cursed.
A new sensational story now could be how such stories are routinely manufactured.
Tradition or culture, call it by any other, these sort of practices make us look primitive and stand out in stark contrast to the rest of our "Vedic" beliefs.
I wonder why there is no culture where they marry snakes, lions or lizards... Maybe availability? Or perhaps these animals (dogs, pigs, donkeys, etc) have some mysterious powers that the acharyas - sankara, ramanuja & madhva - overlooked during their analysis of the scriptures?
I wonder why there is no culture where they marry snakes, lions or lizards... Maybe availability? Or perhaps these animals (dogs, pigs, donkeys, etc) have some mysterious powers that the acharyas - sankara, ramanuja & madhva - overlooked during their analysis of the scriptures?
tks
0
Sri Auh
I usually look forward to reading your comments even if I may or may not agree !
Having said that let me also say that "சும்மா மொட்ட தலைக்கும் மொழங்காலுக்கும் முடிச்சு போடக்கூடாது..." i
When one has genuine freedom of expression all kinds of ideas and rituals will surface in a society . All religions including many under Hinduism umbrella deal with strange beliefs. For the believer they may not seem strange.
But the teachings of Sri Sankara starts only after religious boundaries stop. I assume same may be true for other Acharyas.
There are many emotional slokas 'dripping with Bhakti' attributed to Sri Sankara. It does not matter if that attribution is true or not because those do not contradict any of his commentaries. He never described anything outlandish in his commentaries.
Knowledge parts of Vedic teaching is a total break-away and 180 degrees turn from all the ritualistic aspects of vedas (and for a very good reason - possibly a different topic). However some Hindu rituals are based on Mantras of the vedic vision expounded in the knowledge segments.
But today most people do not know or care to know the connection. Those in the profession of priests do not know as well and often make something up when asked for an explanation.
Snakes are worshipped in pits in certain parts of India. Live rats have a temple (Karni Mata Temple - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia)
Our system of beliefs do not make us look anymore primitive than the beliefs described in the biblical religions. Many of those beliefs tend to be harmful too.
In short I do not agree with your conclusions.
My take is "let us live and let live" provided someone's beliefs do not cause major harm to others.
Shri tks,
Where does the line gets drawn , and by whom or what? Certainly not people like us but the parties involved. "Live and let live"? Dear sir, you do have a sense of dark humour (no offense intended). The quoted phrase indicates understanding and acceptance, with all parties concerned willing to undergo the act. Not forced rituals, for fear of society, superstition or simply, a case of an iron fisted father.
Since superstition and fear ties up the individual from head to toe, I guess, the mudicchu is right on intentions...
Regards & cheers
Where does the line gets drawn , and by whom or what? Certainly not people like us but the parties involved. "Live and let live"? Dear sir, you do have a sense of dark humour (no offense intended). The quoted phrase indicates understanding and acceptance, with all parties concerned willing to undergo the act. Not forced rituals, for fear of society, superstition or simply, a case of an iron fisted father.
Since superstition and fear ties up the individual from head to toe, I guess, the mudicchu is right on intentions...
Regards & cheers
- Status
Share this page
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
- V.Balasubramani
- Chit Chat [Archives]
