How do we claim who as Indian who were born before 1947?

[prasad1]

Share:

Facebook X (Twitter) WhatsApp Email Share Link

Aurangzeb was born on 3 November 1618, in Dahod, Gujarat. He was the third son and sixth child of Shah Jahan and Mumtaz Mahal.

Is Aurangzeb Hindustani, Indian (even though he was muslim and persecuted Hindus).



Alauddin Khilji was born Ali Gurshasp to Shihabuddin Masud and had 3 brothers. He was born in the year 1266-1267 in Birbhum district in West Bengal.

He destroyed many Hindu Kingdoms.

Again was he Hindustani, Bengali, Indian?

 

[msrinivasan1995]

for muslims nation doesn't matter, religion only matters. That's why they waged war on Hind, which they failed even after having 600 years of rule. More over India is an English translation real name is bharat taken from Mahabharat.

 

[prasad1]

L. K. Advani was born in Karachi in a Sindhi Hindu family of businessmen to parents Kishanchand D. Advani and Gyani Devi.
He is Hindu and Indian.

I think us Indian are brainwashed.
Jaykay767ji has been saying this for a long time and he is right. Hindu right-wing has polluted our thinking
We do not think as Indians, we only see Hindus and Muslims.

 

[prasad1]

Mohamad Shami is Muslim, but Indian (particularly when he takes a Hattrick in World cup) otherwise dispensable.

 

[Jaykay767]

This hatred has reached alarming levels and this election showed that this has become mainstream thinking now !

Young kids have all become highly exposed to this incessant propaganda towards minorities via whatsapp and they are building huge animosity and hatred.

An entire generation is growing with this hatred and it will only end up in disaster.

 

[msrinivasan1995]

This hatred has reached alarming levels and this election showed that this has become mainstream thinking now !

Young kids have all become highly exposed to this incessant propaganda towards minorities via whatsapp and they are building huge animosity and hatred.

An entire generation is growing with this hatred and it will only end up in disaster.

Muslims are only radicalised in mosques where are hindu minds are asked to accept what ever bad think they have done. What about Kashmiri pandits problem? do you have any concrete answer, or do you know how ramalingham was murdered three months back in kumbakonam or do you follow the latest news of ISIS infiltration in Coimbatore. That doesn't reach you, the problem with Abrahamic religion is they don't tolerate others as hindus but hindus are always labelled communal. Read about china and how it has dealt islam now days with concentration camps, the seculars wont talk about it as it doesn't support their narrative. ​

 

[msrinivasan1995]

L. K. Advani was born in Karachi in a Sindhi Hindu family of businessmen to parents Kishanchand D. Advani and Gyani Devi.
He is Hindu and Indian.

I think us Indian are brainwashed.
Jaykay767ji has been saying this for a long time and he is right. Hindu right-wing has polluted our thinking
We do not think as Indians, we only see Hindus and Muslims.

Lal Krishna Advani was a hindu and sind was still bharat in those days. Nehru destroyed Indian thinking by promoting western thought process. Those who claim that hindus are intolerant go and read about RJ Rummel Indiana professor work, he quotes Bharat as the only civilisation where lowest killings had happened while the world was fighting for stamping its authority. Marxism involved in education has made hindus feel inferior for what ever we have following, where as white man still follows all the discrimination ( even now black person is discriminated) but that is a progressive society. Go to nation masters, India have lowest crime rates but it narrated india is unsafe for women. India has highest no of muslims, still its peaceful its because of universal acceptance of other faith. We don't charge others but once they start attacking us retaliation is always inevitable.

 

[Janakiram95]

Its easy My grandfather was working for British Indian government as bill collector.He has then promoted as colonial office archives supervisor in London.According to Indian office those people who born in British Indian land and marine boundary is deemed to be Indian and CUKC

 

[prasad1]

Its easy My grandfather was working for British Indian government as bill collector.He has then promoted as colonial office archives supervisor in London.According to Indian office those people who born in British Indian land and marine boundary is deemed to be Indian and CUKC

By your own definition would you call Aurangzeb, and Khilji as Indians?

 

[natkaushik]

India is a geographical concept. The British called it India, when they ruled us. For the muslim- Hind, for the hindus it is BharatVarsh. Country is a western concept formerly denoting a region ruled by a king. When one section of 'Indians' decided that they were a separate nation, Indian nationalism became synonymous with 'Hindu Nationalism'. Dont want to split hairs investigating a dead despot's citizenship. We are tamil brahmins, conservative in following our traditions and practices- acarah paramo dharmah, and liberal in dealing with others- sarve'pi sukhinassantu.

 

[Janakiram95]

By your own definition would you call Aurangzeb, and Khilji as Indians?

At that time there is no country called India and secondly yes they we're bharaths because of their gene mixed with local women's who their ancestors married and converted, Its clearly mentioned in Clive's historical diaries which is now protected by British museum