• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

Pakistanis are basically Hindus, Pakistani lady scholar admits

Status
Not open for further replies.
A candid and fearless opinion voiced by a Pakistani! Appreciate her sentiments! But how may in Pakistan & Bangladesh are willing to follow her!

Pakistanis are basically Hindus, Pakistani lady scholar admits


Monday, 28 September 2015
Written by Ram Kumar Ohri (IPS; retd)

Fauzia_Saeed.jpg



A brave Pakistani lady scholar boldly states what many Indians won't.

In a landmark confession of truth, an enlightened Muslim intellectual, Fauzia Syed, declared during a discussion on a television channel that all Pakistani and Bangladeshi Muslims are essentially Hindus, and that in rare cases, they might be Buddhists.

The lady activist lamented that a lot of Muslims, mainly Pakistani and Bangladeshi, have a hard time accepting the fact that their ancestors were Hindus who were converted by force of sword to Islam. The gutsy lady said this in a live television show while responding to the argument of radical Pakistani Muslim preacher Zaid Hamid.

Syed’s bold assertion of the truth is a clarion call to Hindus to wake up from slumber and re-educate and enlighten the Muslims of the sub-continent about their ancestry and massacres of their forefathers. Unfortunately till now, no Hindu has responded to her wakeup call.

Explaining her viewpoint lucidly, Fauzia said that most Pakistani Muslims believe they are the offspring of the Muslim invaders who came attacking the sub-continent from Muslim lands. But this is an unalloyed falsehood. Any person having a hint of common sense would know that the ancestors of more than 99 percent Pakistanis were Hindus. Unfortunately, Pakistan does not want to admit the bitter truth, nor are the Pakistanis prepared to hear it, she averred.

One simply marvels at the extensively propagated falsehood that Pakistani Muslims are progeny of Arab or Turk invaders. Equally dumb is the assertion that the forefathers of today’s Muslims in Pakistan and India were converted by Sufi saints. Anyone who reads the history of the sub-continent objectively would know that lakhs of Hindus were killed and forcibly converted by Muslim invaders on pain of death. The deep blood relationship between the Muslims and Hindus of the sub-continent is further reinforced by the fact that many surnames like Cheema, Bajwa, Ghakhar, Sethi and also Sehgal (or Saigols) are common to both communities.

Among other things, Fauzia pointed out that it is not wrong to call Pakistan a terrorist state because it has been sheltering terrorists for a long time. The truth was exposed when Osama bin Laden was killed in Pakistan by American
commandos.

It is indeed a sign of the dumbness of Hindu society that this bold Pakistani human rights activist has not been invited to speak in India and interact with the intellectuals, media analysts and common citizens about her incontrovertible true statement on a Pakistani television channel. In any case, the matter deserves the focused attention of the Hindu intelligentsia.

It is not late even now to invite Fauzia Syed to India for a meaningful ‘samvad’ at the India International Centre, New Delhi and then to make her address the Indians in various parts of the country. The opportunity should not be missed and Fauzia Syed must be invited to India for sharing her views with Hindus and Muslims of India. The failure of Hindu society in ignoring the bold and truthful assertion by Fauzia Syed confirms that we continue to be somnolent.

An honest reappraisal of the common heritage of India and Pakistan will totally support Fauzia Syed’s assertion. For centuries, geographically as well as politically, Bharat, i.e., India, included the entire landmass from Bactria (known as Vaahlik Pradesh), the entire Afghanistan, the present day Pakistan, today’s Bharat (i.e., India) and the whole of Bangladesh.

The indescribable savagery of the Muslim invaders unleashed against Hindus of the sub-continent was highlighted by the well known historian, Will Durant, in his book, The Story of Civilization, in the following words:

“The Mohammadan conquest of India is probably the bloodiest story in history. It is a discouraging tale, for its evident moral is that civilization is a precarious thing, whose delicate complex of order and liberty, culture and peace may at any time be overthrown by barbarians invading from without or multiplying within.”

Thus, the bold assertion of Fauzia Syed that the Hindus of Pakistan, nay of the entire sub-continent, were forcibly converted to Islam by sword is absolutely correct. It is time that the gory narrative of the slaughter of Hindu forbears of today’s Pakistani Muslims is brought out of closet and debated publicly by inviting the braveheart Pakistani lady scholar to India.

http://indiatomorrow.co/nation/3892-pakistanis-are-basically-hindus-pakistani-lady-scholar-admits
 
Last edited:
Fauzia Syed being a scholar may submit her papers and get a Phd from any one of the Indian Universities.

It is not any new findings in research.

Of course it is a starting of acceptance of the truth by a Muslim lady.
 
She has said it after somebody had said that everybody in this world is a born Muslim. You cannot help and nobody can.
 
???

Hinduism or Islam or Christianity or Buddhism are religions.

These religions can be professed by any one race in the world.

Race has nothing to do with religion..so its not accurate to say that Pakistani's are basically Hindus.

In fact Pakistani itself is not a race..its a nationality.

Pakistan came into being only in 1947...the place which is present day Pakistan was/is inhabited by Punjabis,Sindhis,Pasthuns and some of Afghan origin too.

Religion in this region had surely been Hinduism first..then Buddhism and finally Islam.

The trend of emergence of religion is not much different from India but India was exposed to much more Christianity in the South Coastal regions becos of the sea route taken by invaders from Europe.

So frankly speaking one can only say that once upon a time..the ancestors of the current day Muslims of Pakistani were professing the Hindu religion.

But which "religion" was practiced before the advent of Hinduism?
 
Last edited:
Pakistani Lady Scholar Fauzia Syed is not alone in this line of thinking. I have come across many intellectuals in
otherside of sub-continent expressing similar view.
Fellow of Royal Geographical Society, Salman Rashid Pakistani author of nine travel books concludes his wonderful
Blog under the title "I, a child of the Maha Sapta Sindhu " with the following words:

"The bottom line is that we who live upon the wide breast of the Sindhu, the father of a civilisation that goes far back into the mists of time, the river that feeds us today and lights up our homes, are the real Hindus.
I, a child of the Maha Sapta Sindhu, should rightfully be called a Hindu."


To read the full Blog please open the following web-link:
http://odysseuslahori.blogspot.in/2013/06/Indus-Civilisation.html

Brahmanyan,
Bangalore.
 
I do not think Bangladeshi Muslims were forcibly converted. There was no bloody conquest of Bengal. However they were lower caste Hindus and untouchables. They despised the upper castes who exploited them. That is why they willingly converted to Hinduism. Interesting even after conversion, they were exploited because the landowners were still upper caste Hindus. It was only partition and the accompanying riots were the Muslims able to finally throw all the Hindus out of Bangladesh.

I would agree with the original post that the Bangladeshis were never Arabs. But neither were Malaysians, Indonesians or Somalis. It is not a unique story.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest ads

Back
Top