• Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

Old wounds: A look at history as 'Sanskrit vs Tamil' debate revives in Parliament

Maha52

Active member
It is Sanskrit which is the root of all our languages,

All our classical literature, our epic texts like the Ramayana and Mahabharata were written in Sanskrit.

We need to preserve our traditions.


Old wounds: A look at history as 'Sanskrit vs Tamil' debate revives in Parliament

"Sanskrit is the mother of all languages, including Tamil, Telugu and Malayalam"

1576410956142.png



Members of the BJP and the DMK engaged in a war of words in Lok Sabha on the evolution of the languages Sanskrit and Tamil, a point of contention since the republic first took birth. Moving the Central Sanskrit Universities Bill, 2019 for consideration and passage, Human Resource Development Minister Ramesh Pokhriyal 'Nishank' said Sanskrit is the greatest language and "soul of the country". "Sanskrit is the oldest language. India was a world leader [vishwaguru] and Sanskrit was its important element," he said.

The debate had taken on fresh dimensions after 2019 Keeladi archaeological excavations in Tamil Nadu. The findings pushed back the date of Tamil-Brahmi to another century—6th century BCE. Literacy or learned the art of writing as early as 6th century BCE; in short, the Sangam era, which marked the largest social and cultural developments in Tamil Nadu, could be much earlier than 300 BCE when it was assumed to have commenced. The findings by the Tamil Nadu archaeological department buttressed that long-held belief of the Dravidian parties that the Indus Valley Civilisation script was proto-Dravidian, related to Tamil, as opposed to Sanskrit (Prakrit) as some studies put it. To put it simplistically, this is the very essence of the Dravidian-Aryan debate in India.

There was also a 2018 study (possibly the one quoted by A. Raja in Parliament yesterday), which claimed the Dravidian language family originated about 4,500 years ago. The Dravidian language family’s four largest languages—Kannada, Malayalam, Tamil and Telugu—have literary traditions spanning centuries, of which Tamil reaches back the furthest, the study had claimed.

Read more at:
 
Last edited:
It is Sanskrit which is the root of all our languages,

All our classical literature, our epic texts like the Ramayana and Mahabharata were written in Sanskrit.

We need to preserve our traditions.


Old wounds: A look at history as 'Sanskrit vs Tamil' debate revives in Parliament

"Sanskrit is the mother of all languages, including Tamil, Telugu and Malayalam"

View attachment 8586


Members of the BJP and the DMK engaged in a war of words in Lok Sabha on the evolution of the languages Sanskrit and Tamil, a point of contention since the republic first took birth. Moving the Central Sanskrit Universities Bill, 2019 for consideration and passage, Human Resource Development Minister Ramesh Pokhriyal 'Nishank' said Sanskrit is the greatest language and "soul of the country". "Sanskrit is the oldest language. India was a world leader [vishwaguru] and Sanskrit was its important element," he said.

The debate had taken on fresh dimensions after 2019 Keeladi archaeological excavations in Tamil Nadu. The findings pushed back the date of Tamil-Brahmi to another century—6th century BCE. Literacy or learned the art of writing as early as 6th century BCE; in short, the Sangam era, which marked the largest social and cultural developments in Tamil Nadu, could be much earlier than 300 BCE when it was assumed to have commenced. The findings by the Tamil Nadu archaeological department buttressed that long-held belief of the Dravidian parties that the Indus Valley Civilisation script was proto-Dravidian, related to Tamil, as opposed to Sanskrit (Prakrit) as some studies put it. To put it simplistically, this is the very essence of the Dravidian-Aryan debate in India.

There was also a 2018 study (possibly the one quoted by A. Raja in Parliament yesterday), which claimed the Dravidian language family originated about 4,500 years ago. The Dravidian language family’s four largest languages—Kannada, Malayalam, Tamil and Telugu—have literary traditions spanning centuries, of which Tamil reaches back the furthest, the study had claimed.

Read more at:
While the 'world is shrinking', as they say, due to 'faster and faster' means of 'transportation and communication devices' or 'media' that break down the barriers of long distances and the time that it takes to traverse the same, yet, paradoxically, the same devices or media are used with exceptional ardour, bordering on vehemence, to heighten the legacy of one's language, religion or belief systems and social, political, economic or cultural heritage, that create deep divisions within the society and leads to unbridgeable chasms that keeps the world 'far apart' in another sense!
 

Latest ads

Back
Top