• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

We have mixed up pilgrimage, a sacred act of devotion, with mass tourism.

Status
Not open for further replies.

mkrishna100

Active member
Mountains into molehills
Vandana Shiva July 04, 2013
Mountains into molehills - Hindustan Times
I was born in, and grew up in the Garhwal Himalaya, which is also called ‘Devbhoomi'. Today, Devbhoomi has been struck by disaster, and the scale of the damage to life and property is closely linked with the way in which we have changed the way we built structures and communities in the fragile mountains. We have become ecologically and culturally confused, and have replaced sustainable living and travel with non-sustainable living and travel.

We have mixed up pilgrimage, a sacred act of devotion, with mass tourism. A pilgrimage is undertaken with a very small ecological footprint, and a heightened consciousness about the sacred earth on which the pilgrim walks, and the sacred site a pilgrim visits.

As long as the visit to the Char Dhams, the sources of the Ganga and its tributaries, was a pilgrimage, the sites were untouched. For over 1,300 years, pilgrims came, and left no footprint. The traditional pilgrim route was along the mountains, from Yamunotri to Gangotri to Kedarnath to Badrinath.

Today's consumer tourism leaves a very heavy footprint on our beautiful and fragile mountains. The careless consumer tourist wants a road up to the shrine. Reckless and limitless construction of roads in the fragile mountains has triggered landslides. The roads are built badly, without culverts and drainage, making the problem of landslides more severe.

In Kedar Ghati, the new breed of tourist even wants helicopter rides to the shrine — something not allowed anywhere in the world near a heritage site.

The pilgrim seeks no luxuries. The consumer tourist wants hotels and flush toilets, which dump the sewage into the sacred rivers. So Devbhoomi is rapidly becoming a slum and a garbage dump. And sadly, this dumping has been aggravated by the mindless ‘relief' of truckloads of plastic water bottles and packets of food.

Traditionally, homes and villages in Garhwal were not built in the flood plains or near river banks. They were built on slopes, and were made of stone walls and slate roofs. The houses were built with local materials and added to the beauty of the landscape.

Consumer tourism has pulled settlements along roadsides, while roads run along the rivers. When a disaster takes place, as just witnessed, the houses and shops are washed away. Hydroelectric projects that dump debris onto the riverbed and the dynamiting of mountains, which trigger landslides, have raised the riverbeds by 20 to 30 metres. With the riverbed this high, old settlements have become vulnerable. The college and school of Agasthamuni have been washed away, even though they were not built on the flood plain, but at a safe distance above the river. The disaster has changed the meaning of safety in the mountains.

A clear example of turning our sacred sites into slums of concrete is Kedarnath. Until a few decades, there were no hotels and concrete structures, just a few dharamshalas. The Kedarnath shrine is perched below a glacier at the source of the beautiful River Mandakini. Geologists had warned that buildings coming up and blocking the flow of the river would one day prove disastrous.

We need to learn from the disaster.
We need to respect our mountains and rivers. We need to rejuvenate indigenous architecture as part of the rehabilitation both because it is better adapted to the local ecosystem and because the non-sustainable transport of iron and cement has been disrupted by the collapse of roads and bridges.

We need to reinvent travel to the Char Dhams,
both to reclaim the culture of the sacred, and to change the paradigm of tourism. Why can't we shift from high-speed, careless, tourism to slow and mindful travel that respects our sacred land, its ecology and culture? We need to stop consuming our sacred sites. We need to stop the slumming of Devbhoomi.

Vandana Shiva is founder of Dehradun-based Research Foundation for Science, Technology and Ecology


The views of the author are personal
 
Vandana Siva has rightly articulated the evolving situation in The Himalayan Pilgrimage Centers.

I love Himalayan Pilgrimages and have been visiting periodically to various holy places from the year 1975 till 2002. Each time I visit I saw the change in the topography,and painfully noticed the beautiful hamlets with small buildings with slate-roofs have vanished and replaced with flat roofed concrete soapboxes. Multi storied rest houses have cropped up replacing quiet Ashrams. The river banks were clustered with modern buildings disturbing the divine serenity of the place.

I have uploaded hereunder the picture of the buildings of an Ashram at Ujjaili, Uttarakashi,the new one built in front. Most of the Ashrams in Uttarakashi are situated in Ujjaili, where at one time outsiders and women were not allowed to roam about after 7 PM at nights during the regime of Maharaja of Tehri.


img5.jpg
The recent deluge is a painful warning of Nature to stop these unholy activities. Geologically the Himalayas are the youngest mountain ranges in the world formed as a result of tectonic plate motion that collided India into Tibet. Because of the great amount of tectonic motion still occurring at the site, the Himalayas have a proportionally high number of earthquakes and tremors.

Let us hope the Government and environmental groups raise-up to the occasion and restore the glory of
these sacred places.

Brahmanyan,
Bangalore.
 
Last edited:
Mountains into molehills
Vandana Shiva July 04, 2013
Mountains into molehills - Hindustan Times

We have mixed up pilgrimage, a sacred act of devotion, with mass tourism. A pilgrimage is undertaken with a very small ecological footprint, and a heightened consciousness about the sacred earth on which the pilgrim walks, and the sacred site a pilgrim visits.


Pilgrimage in Hinduism has been, right from the beginning, a method for brahmins making a living. If one reads old texts which detail the various karmas to be performed as part of each kind of pilgrimage, the ascending order or sequence in which these must be performed, etc., carefully, one will realize the truth of this statement.

Cloudbursts, consequent floods, thousands of deaths etc., are not new. Just read here and scroll down to the sub-heading "India". The modern government has found that anything is good for tourism, internal or foreign. The Indian people are, by and large, completely gullible and will not be convinced that this Chaar Dhaam Yaatra, etc., will not make them gain any religious merits. But why are foreigners coming (if they do, but I am not sure)? Either it is terrorist-linked or sex-linked tourism, according to me.

What is needed is that the government leave the pilgrimage area as it is and let only those people who have the willingness to undertake the pilgrimage despite its extreme hardships venture into it and prove their strength of will. Also, a complete record of each pilgrim - man, woman, child - should be kept at certain locations by making it compulsory for each pilgrim to carry a GPS-enabled e-card identity which can be read by swiping. This card should be surrendered on completion of pilgrimage and the person/s return to the base camp which issued the card. Non-surrender of this card should entail that the person will be treated as dead for all government purposes.
 
krishna,

re your Opening Post, i think, while makes good nostalgic reading, nothing will come out of it.

pilgrim centres' popularity changed with times. and with each, came the accompanying facilities, hosteleries and commercialization. today more people can afford it, there is technology to make covering distances easier, and people have more spare time to take trips.

if at all anything, there is chance of increased tourism and commercialization. not less.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest ads

Back
Top