• This forum contains old posts that have been closed. New threads and replies may not be made here. Please navigate to the relevant forum to create a new thread or post a reply.
  • Welcome to Tamil Brahmins forums.

    You are currently viewing our boards as a guest which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our Free Brahmin Community you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content and access many other special features. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free so please, join our community today!

    If you have any problems with the registration process or your account login, please contact contact us.

Grace in defeat:

Status
Not open for further replies.

Brahmanyan

Active member
I wish to share the following forwarded mail that I received recently. The subject is little old,
but it deserves spending a few minutes of reading.
Brahmanyan,
Bangalore.

*Grace in defeat, a lesson from Britain for Indian ​P​oliticos*
Posted by: Navhind Times May 24, 2015 in Panorama
By KARAN THAPAR

I am an unmitigated — some would say incorrigible — Anglophile and I’ve
always believed there’s a lot that we can learn from this small island
nation. For example, its humour and its willingness to laugh at itself, its
talent for pageantry, the use of the understatement, Westend theatre and
the uniform high quality of its broadcast and print media. Now, let me add
a sixth item to that list: the British knack for responding to political
defeat with grace.Within hours of the result —in fact even before the sun
had set — three political party leaders resigned. They were Ed Miliband of
Labour, Nick Clegg of the Liberal Democrats and Nigel Farage of the UK
Independence Party. They accepted moral responsibility even though they
were not personally to blame. They recognised the need for new leadership.
They accepted that their parties cannot recover under a defeated and
discredited leader.

How different that is to the way we respond. Sonia and Rahul Gandhi reduced
the Congress to just 44 seats but the very thought of resignation did not
occur to them. Mayawati saw her party’s fortunes reduced to zero but,
unconcerned, soldiers on. The DMK was reduced to a mere rump in the
assembly and obliterated in the Lok Sabha elections but the Karunanidhi
family’s control stayed unchanged. The CPI(M) lost Bengal and Kerala and
ended up with their worst Lok Sabha tally but Prakash Karat was unaffected.

I remember John Major’s famous words at two in the morning when it was
clear Tony Blair had swept the Tories aside. “When the curtain falls it’s
time to leave the stage and that’s what I intend to do. Tomorrow I shall be
watching cricket.” Can you imagine any Indian politician similarly rising
from the ashes of defeat?

What our politicians forget —but the British are all too aware of —is they
have a limited shelf life. Once defeated the electorate deserves a new
leader. That new leader has a right to re-fashion the party according to
his or her vision. It’s only then that a democracy provides a critical and
meaningful choice. Simply recycling discredited leaders with the obstinate
insistence that at some point the people will have to opt for them is to
force yourself upon the electorate by wilfully denying them anything else.

I know Jayalalithaa can be cited as proof of the opposite because she’s won
three elections after three defeats. You could say the same of the
Abdullahs or Mulayam Singh. But I believe they prove a different point
about family-based parties or caste based politics. Neither should have a
place in a true democracy.

Finally, the British, you could say, are cruel to defeated leaders. When a
prime minister loses he’s moved out of 10 Downing Street within hours. It
happens swiftly and smoothly.
Usually, defeat is clear by three or four in the morning. Around 11 a.m.
the defeated prime minister leaves Downing Street for Buckingham Palace to
hand back the seals of office. The movers arrive through the back door and
clear out his belongings. After meeting the Queen he departs the palace in
a courtesy car offered by Her Majesty. He’s no longer entitled to the Prime
Minister’s limousine. And he heads for his own home. He cannot return to 10
Downing Street until he has earned the right to do so.

This speed may be harsh but there’s no room for misplaced sentiment in a
democratic transition. The British understand that. Unfortunately, we don’t.

http://www.navhindtimes.in/grace-in-defeat-a-lesson-from-britain-for-indian-politicos/
 
Sir,

The British Ruled us for nearly two hundred years, but our present politicians have no chance to learn lessons from them. :)
 
What the british practiced at home and what they preached and practised in their colonies are quite different. Post world war II, they have evolved a system which is under increasing stress.

We cannot follow british ways, a monolithic population. I have lived in UK for a decade.
 
somebody forwarded a speech by jaggi recently... in it he says that culture is an idea, shaped by what we learn about it... and goes on to talk about the achievements of ancient indians - indian architecture in lebanon, angkor thom etc.. he says that we do not read about the greatness of our culture in schools, but only the aspects of invasion, conquests, rape and loot. hence a meek idea of our culture has its imprint on our mind. an idea of surrender and despondency.

the more we know about our true past, the more proud we would feel; the more proud we feel about our culture the more we would strive to keep it afloat; the effort to keep it up would make us more honourable. and hence history has to be re-written, he says.


"our" is to be understood as hindu culture.

i do not harbour a hatred for the british or for karan thapar, but dont have sympathy for desi-loathing anglophiles...
:)
 
Last edited:
In india ,politicians are like cats . They have nine lives.

one defeat does not make them bow out of politics.

our people also do not mind voting back defeated politicians.

experience could mellow politicians.

we as voters believe in forgive and forget.

we are like that only.lol
 
hi

even many former and defeated MPs are living in govt quarters in delhi....this is called MERA BHARAT MAHAAN attitude...YAHAAM

SAB KUCH CHALTA HAI BHAI....
 
Sir Winston Leonard Spencer Churchil (Winston Churchill) said what his principle moto was.
In defeat defiance ; in victory magnanimity “

The Indian politicians follow the first part meticulously for their convenience.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest ads

Back
Top